Version 1.6 Edit
Upon entering Castle Velis through a secret passage with Leroy, Suki finds Nataleigh in the dungeon with a bound and gagged Carol talking to two guards explaining how she caught her sneaking around the library. One of the guards then notices Suki and Nataleigh assumes she's with her. Despite Suki's response to the accusation, she orders the guards to seize her. After being defeated, she is taken to the hideout and Suki uses the library key she took to sneak through the castle. Afterwards she becomes a Personal Captive.
Version 1.8 Edit
After meeting Carol and leaving the cellar for the solar, Suki sees Nataleigh ordering two guards to bring any suspicious persons, particularly Carol, to her room personally. If the opportunity to listen in on the guards after the maid leaves is taken, they will learn about her unusual practice of tying up girls and taking them to her room, even when those who aren't thieves. After Suki and Carol kidnap most of the noblewomen residing in the manor, they see a noble girl named Emilia entering a previously locked room and attempt to kidnap her, only finding her already bound and gagged. Though Suki is successful with the last kidnapping, Nataleigh walks in during the process, and upon seeing Carol, calls for a guard who binds the thief and brings her to Nataleigh's room. Suki sneaks into the room, after depositing her last victim with Leroy, to observe the beginning of Carol's imminent interrogation by the head maid. Though Nataleigh is drawn away by Emilia's disappearance, allowing Suki to free her ally, she then immediately returns, and catches the both of them, immediately summoning two guards to aid her. After losing her guards and the fight, Nataleigh is brought to the Lair, where she is imprisoned in the Trophy Hall and made a captive for Suki in the Private Cell.
After Krystina's defeat, she is freed alongside the rest of Suki's captives and returns to her duties as Cherisa's loyal maid.
Nataleigh is very strict and bossy, ordering the guards to send all captured intruders in the manor to her room, and even deriding them for their combat deficiencies when overpowered. She does not take nonsense easily; she is more than willing to assign extra guards to patrol if she feels that a thief (namely and quite often, Carol) is present. She also has a darker and/or kinky side; a few guards gossip that she has been known to take women into her room tied up, substantiated by the fact she brings Carol immediately to her room instead of the dungeon. She is mostly unconcerned with retrieving stolen valuables when Carol is in her possession, instead implying that Carol will be "convinced", and then allowed to tell her where the stolen items are.
In the Private Cell, she has a strong will, remaining confident in her inevitable victory over her captors and boasting of the humiliating things Suki will be made to do in her service once she is rescued from the Guild. She also attempts to convince Suki to switch roles with her often. While her will is nigh unbreakable, her kinky side can become very obvious if pressed.
Version 1.6 Edit
She is far more timid in this version than in 1.7 while in combat; however, her kinky nature remains when interacting in the Private Cell.
- Suki had heard rumors of Nataleigh's dark side before even embarking on the mission, referencing them when listening into her conversation with the guards.
- Nataleigh was known merely as "The Maid" until the v1.6.4 release.